• Subscribe
  • Log In
  • Sign up for email updates
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Texas Lawbook

Free Speech, Due Process and Trial by Jury

  • Appellate
  • Bankruptcy
  • Commercial Litigation
  • Corp. Deal Tracker/M&A
  • GCs/Corp. Legal Depts.
  • Firm Management
  • White-Collar/Regulatory
  • Pro Bono/Public Service/D&I

Dearth of Jury Trials Puts Courtroom Skills at a Premium

paidcntnt1

By Clayton Bailey and Alexander Brauer
Partners at Bailey Brauer

Over the last 15 years, the number of jury trials in Texas has declined significantly. As has been reported by this publication, jurors in state and federal civil courts heard only about a third as many cases in 2012 as they did in 1997.

Clayton Bailey
Clayton Bailey
There are many reasons behind this trend, including the effects of tort reform, the rising cost of litigation, and the increased use of alternative dispute resolution methods, among others. But one undeniable effect is that, while there are countless litigators in Texas, there are very few attorneys with demonstrated experience taking cases to trial, and even fewer with significant appellate experience.

The attorneys at Bailey Brauer, however, have an extensive track record of trial victories in state and federal courts, including client wins in some of the nation’s most challenging jurisdictions. Our complex commercial litigation victories include many dismissals, summary judgments and directed verdicts, but we have also handled more than our fair share of successful jury trials. In fact, we have been called in to take on cases shortly before the eve of trial, after the client has become unsure of the previous counsel’s courtroom abilities.

Alexander Brauer
Alexander Brauer
Even more unusual than a wealth of courtroom experience, however, are demonstrated appellate skills. And our attorneys have had more successful appellate rulings than firms many times our size. We have argued — and won — cases before the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Louisiana Supreme Court, Mississippi Supreme Court, 2nd Court of Appeals in Fort Worth and other state and federal appellate courts. Not only have we won reversals and remands and preserved favorable judgments, but we also have obtained an en banc rehearing before the 5th U.S. Circuit that resulted in a major, precedent-setting decision protecting an entire industry.

Bailey Brauer was founded by two former members of one of the world’s largest law firms. Our big firm experience schooled us in the ways of complex litigation and appellate work. The knowledge we gained handling some of the country’s biggest lawsuits for major national and international clients was invaluable. Ultimately, however, we decided that our clients would be better served if we were in a boutique law firm that would allow us to provide them with the same level of service in a more flexible and nimble environment.

Time and again, we have found that few attorneys, regardless of the size of their firm, have had the kind of courtroom experience we provide. And we have discovered that our experience arguing cases before juries and trial and appellate judges is one of the main strengths that set us apart from our competitors.

Granted, most lawsuits never see the inside of a courtroom beyond the most preliminary of discovery disputes. Of the federal lawsuits filed within the 5th Circuit’s jurisdiction (which includes Texas), only 1.4 percent reach the trial phase, according to statistics compiled by the Judicial Business of the United States Courts and published in Litigation, the Journal of the American Bar Association’s Litigation Section (membership required). Of the handful that goes to trial, even fewer are taken up on appeal. But “hoping for the best” (summary judgment or early dismissal) isn’t usually a wise litigation strategy. At Bailey Brauer, we believe that “preparing for the worst” (a hard-fought trial and possible appeal) often represents the best way to bring about an early resolution.

baileylgo1

In one recent example, our clients—both of which are large, international companies—were served with a RICO complaint on Sept. 9. RICO allegations are serious and referred to as a “thermonuclear device” in the litigation arena because of their in terrorem effect on defendants. After being retained, we immediately responded with a robust motion to dismiss, and the plaintiffs voluntarily dismissed their complaint on Oct. 15.

In another example, our client was seeking to recover funds that were misappropriated by a former employee. Another law firm issued the initial demand letter and attempted to resolve the matter short of litigation. After having no success, the client retained us to take the matter to trial. Shortly after we filed suit and began to put on the pressure, the former employee relented and agreed to pay the full amount owed.

In another case, our client was on the receiving end of a mandatory buyout under a partnership agreement with a purchase price that drastically undervalued her ownership interests. We filed suit and moved for summary judgment within two weeks of the defendants filing their answer. The defendants then agreed to settle the matter – at a price our client was very pleased with – within weeks of our motion being filed.

So our opponents know we’re not bluffing when we say, “See you in court.”

Clearly, our skills and our track record are a major aspect of our appeal to large, corporate clients with high-stakes legal disputes. Equally important is our ability to do the same level of sophisticated legal work as the world’s largest law firms, but we do it more cost-effectively.

Because we are a boutique firm, we have minimal overhead and a singular focus. We also offer flexibility in billing arrangements. We have entered into a variety of alternative billing agreements with our clients that offer predictability as well as the prospect of sharing the potential risks and rewards of litigation.

Reducing the cost of litigation does more than simply bring down a client’s legal bills; it profoundly changes the decision-making on the front end of a major piece of litigation. If a business client anticipates spending far more in legal fees than it hopes to recover (or avoid paying in damages), the company is likely to enter into a settlement that may not be in its long-term best interest.

If, however, the legal fees for taking a case to trial are manageable, then the odds of that client throwing in the towel prematurely are greatly reduced. And if the attorney offers the same level of expertise as the “name brand” law firm, then the math is even easier.

General counsel need to know — and be able to tell their CEO and board — that their company has a lawyer with the street cred and gravitas to handle high-stakes matters. Bailey Brauer offers those general counsel the brand name attorneys they love, but at a price that leaves CFOs smiling.

Clayton Bailey and Alexander Brauer are the co-founders of Bailey Brauer PLLC, which focuses on complex commercial litigation, agribusiness, appeals, and class and collective actions. For more information, visit baileybrauer.com. Mr. Bailey can be reached at cbailey@baileybrauer.com, and Mr. Brauer can be reached at abrauer@baileybrauer.com.

paidcntnt1

Primary Sidebar

Features

  • P.S. — Pro Bono Turkeys and Fixings  - A short and sweet P.S. this week highlights two Thanksgiving-themed public service efforts led by Winston & Strawn, a name partner at Lynn Pinker Hurst & Schwegmann and the Dallas Volunteer Attorney Program. Plus: a movie recommendation. November 22, 2023Natalie Posgate

GCs, Lawyers & Firms

  • The Corner Office: Q&A with Trey Cox - In this new thought leadership series, Dallas legal recruiter Kate Cassidy talks with Gibson Dunn's Trey Cox about litigation trends in Texas, career advice for young attorneys, what he's reading right now and more.
  • Blank Rome Bolsters White Collar Defense Group as DOJ Investigations, Prosecutions Increase
  • Jeremy Wallace: From Air Force Language Analyst to Lawyer Giving Back to Vets 
  • Litigation Boutique Burns Charest Nabs Longtime Assistant U.S. Attorney
  • Administrative Patent Judge Joins Bracewell’s IP Practice in Austin 
  • Hispanic Heritage Month Spotlight: Norton Rose Fulbright COO Stacey Martinez
  • Sorrels Law Expands Footprint in Austin, Hires Veteran Lawyer Judy Kostura
  • Former Federal Prosecutor Charles Fowler Returns to McKool Smith
More GCs, Lawyers & Firms

Lawyers in the News

Hover right to see full list

Chris Abbinante
Rebecca L. Adams
Joe Ahmad
Michael J. Aiello
Chris Akin
Michelle Alden
Stephen Alicanti
Thomas Arnst
Jessica Barger
Deno Barroga
Chad Barton
David Beck
Jeff Becker
Jill Bradley
Abby Branigan
Whitney Breheny
Amanda Bridson
Shonn Brown
Ruth Burdick
Catherine Burnett
Brett Busby
Chrysta Castañeda
Sara Chelette
Jonathan Childers
Peter Clarke
Charles T. Collins-Chase
Joseph Connors III
Andrés Correa
Colin Cox
Trey Cox
Rob Crain
Josh Davidson
Alain Dermarkar
Tonja De Sloover
John Dinan
Elysa Dishman
Miriam Domer
Molly Duane
Sarah Dyer
Dan Dyring
Catherine Baker Ellis
Jeremy Fielding
Spencer Finney
Gina Flores
Scott Freeman
Andrianna Frinzi
Richard Frye
Catherine Gallagher
Hilda Galvan
Doug Getten
Sarah George
Marc Gravely
Guy Gribov
Stancell Haigwood
Sophia Han
Deborah Hankinson
Rusty Hardin
Sam Hardy
Matt Hart
Jason Hawkins
Chris Heasley
Marshall Heins II
James Ho
Vinh Ho
Morgan Hollins
Mary Jo Holloway
Hillary Holmes
Renee Hunter
Michael Hurst
Lindsey Jacquillard
Ellyn Josef
Evan Kastner
Dan Kelly
Emily Kelly
Michael Kenneally
Daniel Kenney
Timothy Kincaid
Dan Komarek
Judy Kostura
Niko Lane
Efren Lemus
Jordan Leon
Paul Linton
Bryan Loocke
Mike Lynn
Kurt Malmquist II
Charles Martin
Michael Masri
Dan McLemore
Raffi Melkonian
Tom Melsheimer
Richard Mithoff
Bill Munck
Wendy J. Murphy
James Musselman
Roald Nashi
Aaron Nielson
Mary Goodrich Nix
Paul Nolette
Mark Oakes
Bryan Parrish
Griffin Peeples
Julie Pettit
Lanora C. Pettit
Michael Piazza
James Pikl
Edward Piña
Eric Pinker
Ryan Poche
Clint Rancher
Mark Ray
Cara E. Regan
Zach Rider
Ashley S. Rogers
Byron Romain
Christine Robb
Brian Rosenzweig
Bethany Salpietra
Omar Samji
Michelle Sargent
Chris Schwegmann
Anand K. Sharma
Charles Siegel
Elliott Smith
Jason C.N. Smith
Erin Snody
Joseph Soliz
Richard Stanley
Britta Stanton
Brantley Starr
Sarah Stewart
Steve Stodghill
Justin Sumner
Steve Sumner
Tara Tegeleci
David Thompson
Jeff Tillotson
Aaron Tobin
Griffin Tolle
Julie Ungerman
Marcel Valenta
Samuel Wales
Jordan Warshauer
Tom Wheeler
Ray Winter
Travis Wofford
Paul Yetter
Hailee Yip
John Zavitsanos

Firms in the News

Hover right to show full list

3E
Academic Partnerships
Alston & Bird
Altus Power
A&M Law
ANSCU
Apollo
AZA
Baker Botts
Baylor Law
Beard Kultgen
Betterleave
Burleson Pate
BYU Law
CATEC
Center for Reproductive Rights
Cooper & Kirk
CSC
DLA Piper
DOJ
Finnegan Henderson 
First Lockhart
Gibson Dunn
Goldwater
Greater Sum
Handraise
Haynes Boone
Helix Energy
Hess Midstream
Highwoods Realty
Holland & Knight
Intersect Power
Jones Walker
Kastner Gravelle
Kaufman Hall
Kirkland
Latham
Lynn Pinker
Mach Natural Resources
Marquette
Morgan Lewis
Munck Wilson
New England Law
NLRB
Norton Rose Fulbright
Nova Chemicals
Novant Health
Operio
Paloma Partners
Pettit Firm
Preston Hollow Community Capital
PyroPhyte
Reed Smith
Scheef & Stone
Shearman & Sterling
Sidley
Simpson Thacher
Sio Silica
Skadden
Sorrels Law Firm
Sprouse Shrader Smith
Stanley Reuter
STCL
Summit Midstream
Sumner Schick
TAJF
Tata
Tenet Healthcare
Teradyne
Texas AG Office
UT Law
V&E
Virdee
Vitol
Waters & Kraus
Weil
West Webb 
White & Case
WhiteHawk
Wiley
Winston & Strawn
Wright Close & Barger

Footer

Who We Are

  • About Us
  • Our Team
  • Contact Us
  • Submit a News Tip

Stay Connected

  • Sign up for email updates
  • Article Submission Guidelines
  • Premium Subscriber Editorial Calendar

Our Partners

  • Houston Chronicle
  • Dallas Business Journal
The Texas Lawbook logo

1409 Botham Jean Blvd.
Unit 811
Dallas, TX 75215

214.232.6783

© Copyright 2023 The Texas Lawbook
The content on this website is protected under federal Copyright laws. Any use without the consent of The Texas Lawbook is prohibited.