• Subscribe
  • Log In
  • Sign up for email updates
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Texas Lawbook

Free Speech, Due Process and Trial by Jury

  • Appellate
  • Bankruptcy
  • Commercial Litigation
  • Corp. Deal Tracker/M&A
  • GCs/Corp. Legal Depts.
  • Firm Management
  • White-Collar/Regulatory
  • Pro Bono/Public Service/D&I

Texas Panel Trims Vitol Americas’ Win by $10.5M, Leaves $129M Intact

September 13, 2022 Michelle Casady

Most of an award in favor of Vitol Americas Corp. was upheld Tuesday by a Texas appellate panel that determined $129 million in damages tied to breach of contract in the suit over a soured deal for a crude oil storage and processing facility can stand.

A three-justice panel of the Fourteenth Court of Appeals did trim the award, however, finding that the energy and commodity trading company couldn’t also hang on to about $10.5 million in damages stemming from a fraud claim against midstream resource management company Targa Channelview.

Chief Justice Tracy Christopher, writing for the panel, noted that even Vitol didn’t object to the elimination of those damages because Harris County District Judge Larry Weiman, who presided over the five-week bench trial, awarded those damages on a theory Vitol had disclaimed in the litigation.

“Vitol pleaded that Targa fraudulently induced the agreement and fraudulently misrepresented the capacity of Targa’s dock, but the trial court rejected both of those theories in its findings of fact and conclusions of law,” Justice Christopher wrote. “The trial court instead awarded Vitol fraud damages based on the theory Targa failed to provide Vitol with updates on the construction of the splitter facility.”

Judge Weiman’s final judgment, signed Oct. 23, 2020, also awarded Vitol $17.6 million in prejudgment interest on the contract claim.

The dispute between the companies is rooted in a December 2015 agreement under which Vitol would deliver crude to a so-called “splitter facility” where crude oil is separated into various products that would be built, owned and operated by Targa.

When Targa failed to build the facility 27 months later, as required under the deal, Vitol terminated the agreement, according to the opinion, and filed suit alleging breach of contract and that Targa had fraudulently misrepresented the capacity of the facility.

Under the deal, Vitol was required to pay Targa about $43 million annually, and when the agreement fell apart there was $129 million in the account Vitol had paid into. In the lawsuit, it sought all of those funds and additional damages for the fraud claim.

Justices Frances Bourliot and Randy Wilson also sat on the panel.

Vitol is represented by Macey Reasoner Stokes, Anthony J. Lucisano and Elisabeth C. Butler of Baker Botts and Lee L. Kaplan, Garland “Land” Murphy, Eugene Zilberman and Johnathan Mondel of Smyser Kaplan & Veselka.

Targa is represented by David Keltner, Joe Greenhill, Caitlyn E. Hubbard and Jacob A. deKeratry of Kelly Hart & Hallman, David M. Gunn and Erin H. Huber of Beck Redden, Thomas C. Wright and Rachel H. Stinson of Wright Close & Barger, William J. Boyce of Alexander Dubose & Jefferson, Jennifer Caughey and Danica L. Milios of Jackson Walker and Timothy C. Shelby, Daryl L. Moore, Ryan Hackney, Jason S. McManis, Paul Turkevich and Monica Uddin of Ahmad Zavitsanos & Mensing.

The cause number is 14-21-00048-CV.

Michelle Casady

Michelle Casady is based in Houston and covers litigation and appeals — including trials, breaking news and industry trends — for The Texas Lawbook.

View Michelle’s articles

Email Michelle

©2025 The Texas Lawbook.

Content of The Texas Lawbook is controlled and protected by specific licensing agreements with our subscribers and under federal copyright laws. Any distribution of this content without the consent of The Texas Lawbook is prohibited.

If you see any inaccuracy in any article in The Texas Lawbook, please contact us. Our goal is content that is 100% true and accurate. Thank you.

Primary Sidebar

Recent Stories

  • Baker Hughes’ ‘Fearless’ VP of Litigation: Teresa Garcia-Reyes 
  • CDT Roundup: Power Moves Supercharge the Week
  • Defying Political Backlash, Susman Godfrey Expands Diversity Scholarship Amid Legal Battle with Trump Administration
  • Blackstone to Acquire TXNM Energy for $11.5B
  • Kirkland is Texas’ First Billion-Dollar Law Firm

Footer

Who We Are

  • About Us
  • Our Team
  • Contact Us
  • Submit a News Tip

Stay Connected

  • Sign up for email updates
  • Article Submission Guidelines
  • Premium Subscriber Editorial Calendar

Our Partners

  • The Dallas Morning News
The Texas Lawbook logo

1409 Botham Jean Blvd.
Unit 811
Dallas, TX 75215

214.232.6783

© Copyright 2025 The Texas Lawbook
The content on this website is protected under federal Copyright laws. Any use without the consent of The Texas Lawbook is prohibited.