SCOTX To Orca: ‘Vague Assurances’ Should Have Been A Clue

In hot pursuit of mineral leases in the frenzied 2010 Eagle Ford Shale play, Orca Assets paid $3.2 million for six leases in DeWitt County that they later discovered belonged to another company. Rather than simply accept a return of their cash, Orca sued the owner’s agent, accusing them of fraud, demanding $400 million in unrealized revenues. On Friday, the Texas Supreme Court suggested that Orca should have known better. Janet Elliott reports on the court’s reasoning in The Texas Lawbook.

March 26, 2018 Janet Elliott

SCOTX Upholds Legislative Tax Formulas

In a decision that could significantly impact school funding in the oil patch, the Texas Supreme Court ruled that statutory formulas setting valuations for business and personal property are not unconstitutional. Janet Elliott explains the ruling in The Texas Lawbook.

March 5, 2018 Janet Elliott

Analysis: Is Dallas Appeals Court Ready for a Shake Up?

There are 31 different appellate judgeships on primary ballots across Texas. But the Fifth Court of Appeals should get more attention than the rest. Eight of the 13 seats on the Dallas appeals court are up for election. There are two vacancies, the chief judge’s chair is open and Democrats have narrowed the vote margins in recent years. With an unprecedented number of judicial spots up this election cycle, the Fifth Court has the potential to undergo dramatic and transformational change.

March 2, 2018 Mark Curriden

Texas Courts’ Passion for Arbitration Continues in Payday Lender & Dallas Topless Club Cases

Proponents of binding mandatory arbitration scored two huge victories this week in the Texas appellate courts. In two separate and unrelated rulings, the Texas Supreme Court and the Dallas Court of Appeals ordered plaintiffs in two cases – a group of customers alleging they were illegally victimized by a payday lender and an exotic dancer suing a strip club for gross negligence – to litigate their claims through private arbitration instead of the public court system.

March 2, 2018 Janet Elliott

SCOTX: Lawyer-Client Privilege Applies to Patent Agents

Patent agents who provide authorized legal services may invoke attorney-client privilege to withhold client communications, the Texas Supreme Court ruled Friday. The ruling supports Andrew Silver, the inventor of tablet technology for ordering and paying the tab at a restaurant. Silver claims Tabletop Media failed to pay him for his patent and is fighting a Dallas trial court’s order compelling the production of emails between Silver and his non-attorney patent agent. The Texas Lawbook has complete details.

February 26, 2018 Janet Elliott

SCOTX: Mental Anguish Damages Possible for Negligent Mishandling of Corpse

Mental anguish damages might be available in a case alleging negligent mishandling of a corpse, the Texas Supreme Court ruled Friday, sending a recently argued case back to a Brown County court for trial. The justices upheld a ruling by the 11th Court of Appeals in Eastland that Nelson, Lobban’s only adult child, had common law and statutory rights as next of kin to determine the disposition of his mother’s remains.

February 26, 2018 Janet Elliott

Flying Pig Spotted: Fifth Circuit Grants Mandamus Relief in Privilege Dispute

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit is famously reluctant to grant a mandamus petition. The court recently invoked authority from 1881 as the reason for denial. But last week, a Fifth Circuit panel in a case that received little attention granted mandamus relief as to a finding of an extensive waiver of attorney-client privilege. This Texas Lawbook article explains the case and why it matters.

February 26, 2018 David Coale

Texas Appeals Court Upholds $288M Ruling for Highland Capital v. Credit Suisse

The Dallas Court of Appeals Tuesday upheld a lower court ruling for Dallas investment firm Highland Capital Management to recover nearly $288 million from Swiss bank Credit Suisse for a real estate deal gone wrong in the run up to the 2008 financial crisis. This Dallas Business Journal report has the details.

February 22, 2018 Jon Prior of the Dallas Business Journal

Take-Nothing Arbitration Win Ends 10-year Hurricane Dolly Claim

A take-nothing arbitration ordered by the Texas Supreme Court effectively ends 10 years of litigation over a storm-damaged condominium project on South Padre Island. The dispute, over insurance coverage after Hurricane Dolly, saw an endorsement of oft-cited arbitration waiver rules. The Texas Lawbook fully explains.

February 21, 2018 Allen Pusey

SCOTX Asked to Settle Retained Acreage Disputes

Advances in fracking technology and increased oil prices have helped gain significant production from oil fields once thought to be dry losers. But confusion between regulatory filings and existing oil and gas lease agreements are fueling industry conflicts that need to be resolved by SCOTX. Janet Elliott has the details in The Texas Lawbook.

February 12, 2018 Janet Elliott

Texas Lawyers Rate Appellate Judges Up for Election

The State Bar of Texas' poll of lawyers shows that there are a handful of appellate judges across the state that garner great respect from a large percentage of members of the Texas bar, but the state’s highest court continues to be divisive.

February 7, 2018 Mark Curriden

SCOTX Rules Oncor Must Pay Moving Costs

When it comes to relocating utility wires and poles when roadways are widened, the Texas Supreme Court says the old rules are still the rules. Read Janet Elliott's account of Friday's decision in The Texas Lawbook.

February 5, 2018 Janet Elliott